An illustrative example: a strategy team asks its CFO to approve an AI tool that rebuilds the competitor model every week from filings, earnings calls, job postings, and pricing pages. The pitch is that the annual plan is now too slow. Before signing, the CFO should ask one question. When the model refreshes, which decision changes, and who has the authority to change it?
If nobody can answer, the tool will produce better analysis that nobody acts on. Research on how large decisions get made suggests that the process around the analysis matters more than the analysis itself, and cheaper analysis does not change the process.
Analysis was rarely the constraint
In 2010, Dan Lovallo and Olivier Sibony published a study of 1,048 major business decisions in McKinsey Quarterly: investments in new products, acquisitions, and large capital projects. They compared two things: the quantity and detail of the analysis behind each decision, and the quality of the process used to make it. Process mattered more than analysis, by a factor of six. McKinsey's analysis of returns found that moving a company from the bottom to the top quartile on decision process improved its return on investment by 6.9 percentage points.9 percentage point higher return on investment.
AI makes analysis faster and cheaper. A language model can summarize a year of a competitor's earnings calls in minutes. That improves the smaller of the two factors. The larger one, the process by which a leadership team weighs evidence, surfaces dissent, and commits, is unchanged by the tool.
So the first change AI requires is to the process that receives the analysis.
Money does not move as fast as the analysis
A second study shows where the process sticks. Stephen Hall, Dan Lovallo, and Reinier Musters reviewed more than 1,600 US companies between 1990 and 2005 (McKinsey Quarterly, 2012). Across all industries, the mean correlation between the capital a business received in one year and the year before was 0.92. Budgets mostly followed last year's budgets. Yet the top third of companies by reallocation earned, on average, 30 percent higher total returns to shareholders annually than the bottom third.
A weekly competitor model attached to an annual allocation process produces fifty-one updates that cannot move money. Match the refresh rate to the reallocation rate. If capital can move only once a year, a quarterly signal reviewed against explicit reallocation triggers is worth more than a weekly signal reviewed by nobody.
The practical step is to write the triggers down in advance. For each major bet, state the evidence that would cause you to add funding, hold, or pull back, and who decides. AI monitoring can then watch for those specific signals instead of everything. An illustrative trigger, with made-up thresholds: if our largest competitor cuts its mid-market list price by more than 10 percent for two consecutive quarters, the pricing committee reviews our tier within 30 days.
Scenarios: more is not the goal
Shell has used scenario planning since the late 1960s and early 1970s. Pierre Wack, who led the work, described it in a 1985 Harvard Business Review article, "Scenarios: Uncharted Waters Ahead". His point was that scenarios exist to change the mental models of the people making decisions, not to predict the future.
AI can generate dozens of scenarios from a set of variables in an afternoon. That is useful for one job: stress-testing the assumptions under the plan you already have. It is not useful as a stack of futures for executives to read. A leadership team that cannot hold four scenarios in mind will not hold forty.
Use the tool to find which assumptions move the outcome most, then build a small number of scenarios around those. Each one should name the decision it would change.
Test the data advantage before you bank on it
A common claim is that proprietary data plus AI creates an advantage competitors cannot copy. Martin Casado and Peter Lauten of Andreessen Horowitz examined that claim in 2019 in "The Empty Promise of Data Moats". Their argument: the cost of adding unique data can rise while the value of each additional data point falls, and data goes stale as competitors collect the same information. In their words, the moat can erode as the corpus grows.
That does not mean data never matters. It means the claim needs testing for your case. Two checks help:
- Train or evaluate the model on half your data. If accuracy barely drops, more data is not your advantage.
- Ask how long the data stays predictive. If data more than a year old adds little to the current model, the advantage has to be renewed continuously, which makes it an operating cost to budget for each year.
What to automate in competitive monitoring
Reading is where AI helps most. Filings, earnings transcripts, patent publications, regulatory submissions, and job postings are public, long, and slow to read. Summarizing them and flagging changes against last quarter is work a model does well and quickly.
Two rules keep it honest. Every alert should link to the source document, because language models can misstate what a document says. And every alert should map to one of the triggers you wrote down. A feed of facts with no decision attached is a reading list.
What stays with the leadership team
Lovallo and Sibony's findings point to process tools that do not depend on AI at all. Gary Klein's premortem, described in Harvard Business Review in 2007, asks a team to imagine the plan has failed and explain why, which makes dissent safe to voice. A decision log records what was decided, on what evidence, and what would change the decision, so the next review can check the reasoning against what happened.
AI can prepare the inputs for both. It cannot decide which risks the company will accept, or what kind of company it wants to be. Those choices are why the leadership team exists.
A first step
Take the last three major allocation decisions your leadership team made. For each, write down what evidence was presented, what was decided, and whether any evidence could have changed the outcome. If the answer is that the decision was set before the analysis arrived, faster analysis will not help. Start with the process: the triggers, the reallocation calendar, and the decision log. Then choose the AI tools that feed them.
GradeCircle builds and runs six products of its own: AfroSynergy, CallerBridge, HealthSquire, Heyzl, Lexfora, and LukeAPI, two of them in beta. The assumptions in our models come from operating those systems, not from a framework. See what we run.
If you have a specific decision in front of you, scope it in five questions and see the engagement, price band, and timeline before sharing contact details.



